The IT Law Wiki


Olympic Insurance Co. v. Harrison, Inc., 418 F.2d 669 (5th Cir. 1969) (full-text).

Factual Background[]

The plaintiff sued for the amount due on an insurance premium.

Trial Court Proceedings[]

In a motion for summary judgment, the plaintiff offered an IBM statement of an itemized bill as part of its affidavit. The trial court granted the motion.

Appellate Court Proceedings[]

The defendant appealed, asserting that the IBM printouts were not reliable, and therefore, a genuine issue of material fact existed as to the amount due and it was error to grant plaintiff's summary judgment motion.

The Fifth Circuit noted that the IBM printouts are the types of records that come within 28 U.S.C. §1732, and are, therefore, prima facie reliable. In addition, the court noted that the defendant did not object to any specific inaccuracy, but merely alleged general unreliability of the printouts.

The court held that there was no merit in the defendant's contention of unreliability. Without specific objections there was, as the trial court found, no genuine issue of material fact, and summary judgment was properly granted.